12 23Thu05232013

Settings

Font Size

Back Opinion Justice delayed...

Justice delayed...

  • PDF

THERE’s an old saying that when the process of jurisprudence gets bogged down, and cases get hung up in the court system for whatever reason, justice is being denied. Justice delayed is justice denied, is how it goes.

A case in point is the contentious case filed by the losing candidates in the 2010 gubernatorial election. After an initial flurry of activity, with some tantalizing indications there might be some substance to their assertions, the case just sat in the Superior Court. Eventually one of the plaintiffs, former Sen. Frank Aguon, withdrew from the case, and the original attorney for the plaintiffs withdrew as well.

Sure, there was a technical difficulty in the filing of the case that might have derailed it in any case, but we’ll never know. The other plaintiff, former Gov. Carl Gutierrez, finally pulled out, saying he couldn’t afford to proceed and, by implication, indicating he couldn’t find any other lawyer to carry the ball forward.

Throughout 2011, we made regular calls to the courtroom of Judge Arthur Barcinas to find out if anything was happening on this case, if anything was scheduled. We got nowhere. Neither did the case.

More recently, the curious case of legislative candidate Brant McCreadie and the company he and his wife bought, but allegedly didn’t pay for, has surfaced. The curious part is that apparently none of our sitting black robes at the Superior Court are willing to take the case. At least six of them have reportedly recused themselves and another one is considering doing so. An outside judge could be brought in but that’s not being done so far, so that case also languishes, probably until after the election.

Also in judicial limbo is the action taken by the Guam Board of Allied Health Examiners against Dr. Joel Joseph, aka Joel Schiff, and his Wise Owl Animal Hospital. The board handed down a 26-page final decision, findings of fact, conclusions of law and order on June 13. Joseph’s attorney immediately went to the Superior Court and got Judge Michael Bordallo to issue a stay, a temporary stay.

The government, through the Attorney General’s Office, responded on July 2, but since then, nothing. It is a contentious issue, but to simply let it lapse through inaction or failure of the judge to schedule the required hearing on the matter is to give Joseph what he wants. The order suspended his license and instructed him to close his business. Instead, he continues to practice veterinary medicine and operate his clinic, and probably figures he can do so indefinitely.

The AGO needs to go to the Supreme Court and ask for a writ of mandate, ordering the judge to set a hearing date. To simply ignore the GBAHE order and findings is to deny that public board, comprised of volunteer professionals who spent many months on this case, their day in court, in effect denying them, and the public, justice.

Comments  

 
-1 #8 Da 2012-08-18 17:08
Quoting Jose Cruz:
Geeze, another person who thinks the entire system is in the wrong and ONE PERSON is in the right. I can understand diferences of opinion but to spout that the entire universe is in the wrong is demented. Does anyone else see the picture here?

Quoting Da:
Even in this cases above,
The criminals in this case which need to be prosecuted are right here:

AG's office
the federal AG's office
The office of the public auditor
and the Governor of Guam

Vote for new people, these parasites need to go!


Jose Cruz,
if you have some decency, read those e-mails, and don't come back and complain again. You are the one which can not see the very wrong and that the same charlatans who did this are right now jumping around in our government:.

http://s1246.photobucket.com/albums/gg613/dannysab888/?albumview=slideshow
 
 
0 #7 Jose Cruz 2012-08-14 10:41
Geeze, another person who thinks the entire system is in the wrong and ONE PERSON is in the right. I can understand diferences of opinion but to spout that the entire universe is in the wrong is demented. Does anyone else see the picture here?

Quoting Da:
Even in this cases above,
The criminals in this case which need to be prosecuted are right here:

AG's office
the federal AG's office
The office of the public auditor
and the Governor of Guam

Vote for new people, these parasites need to go!
 
 
+2 #6 Jose Cruz 2012-07-24 15:00
Here we go again! Crying like a little baby. What about Mamie Balajadia??? Is your mind "stuck in second gear"? So now EVERYONE is a criminal except your (Michael Phelps) hero? You are pathetic and must not be from here. You are the kind who comes here and says that everyone is stupid and corrupt because you are. You come to my island and think you are better than everyone else. Wherever you are from and whoever you are just go home. Oh, you probably can't go home because you are running away. We don't want people like you here.
 
 
-5 #5 Michael Phelps 2012-07-24 12:35
Responding to MV Editor:
You state that the issue should not be shelved.
What about the Maime Balajadia issue that has been shelved.
I was at the board meeting a year plus ago where Maime demanded to have all questions submitted in writing and has since refused to respond. Her board is a court of sorts and she has definitely made it one for her own good.
Why not answer this issue first as it was "shelved" first.
The reason it has been shelved is Maime has powerful friends. and I bet she can even get her tax refund faster too.
 
 
-2 #4 Da 2012-07-24 10:41
Even in this cases above,
The criminals in this case which need to be prosecuted are right here:

AG's office
the federal AG's office
The office of the public auditor
and the Governor of Guam

Vote for new people, these parasites need to go!
 
 
+8 #3 MVGuam Editor 2012-07-23 16:28
[We have a substantial file on Wise Owl and Dr. Joseph's position on these issues, and we've heard the Mamie Balajadia contention many times. The point of the editorial is that the GBAHE order ought to be argued on its merits in a courtroom, not shelved by dint of a stay which was intended to be only temporary.
 
 
-5 #2 Michael Phelps 2012-07-23 15:49
Jon Andersen finally shows his colors. Either he is being fed a pile of garbage by the AGO or he has failed to even ask the other sides opinions. In regards to the Boards, if he thinks justice is delayed then lets get to the bottom of whether Maime Balajadia is even qualified to hold her post. She does not have the qualificiations and never did. This is a crime against the people of Guam and the mentally ill that she "treats." This was never decided so that the public can see. If this wasn't clarified then how can the courts clarify the cases she sits on. And if she is sitting illegally that means according to the law the AGO has been keeping her in office illegally which is a felony. So the AGO is committing a felony. The problem is with the AGO not the courts. The courts slow down the AGO and their insanity so that the truth has the time to come out. Mr. Andersen - look at the AGO and its crazy actions not the courts. To quote Mr. Jose Cruz --- "are we so spineless and lacking in moral conviction that we can be pushed around ....." only this time it is by people who are in power and totally negligent and unqualified.
 
 
+7 #1 Jose Cruz 2012-07-23 11:19
Finally....this rag has decided to support the decisions made by a government board of professionals. Why have boards when those disciplined can cry, whine, complain, point fingers at everyone else and cry for pity but never accept judgement against them? Are we so spineless and lacking in moral conviction that we can be pushed around by people who have been deemed negligent? We have to protect our community from charlatans that come here and pretend to know everything. Come on my people!
 

Please Login to post a comment.